Our last post highlighted the benefits of using Astro and Forestry CMS (catch up here in case you missed it). Forestry actually shared our post with a really important point that I thought was worth digging into with a proper blog post.
The beauty of embracing open formats like Markdown and JSON on top of Git is that a CMS you designed more than 5 years ago, works perfectly with the latest modern web tooling.— Forestry CMS (@forestryio) August 5, 2021
Now go check @astrodotbuild to ship faster websites 🚀 https://t.co/0o6OgCfkgx
Follow @forestryio on Twitter if you don’t already! Their git-based CMS tools are a huge win for any Jamstack project and should you have any questions or issues, their team is extremely responsive and helpful.
tl;dr; The web development landscape is constantly in flux. It’s easy to see the latest tools, languages, and frameworks get hyped on your favorite blogs and podcasts, but at the end of the day you probably need to build quality sites that can be easily maintained for years. More often than not, the boring tools make your life easier in the long run!
A bit of history
It wasn’t so long ago that sites were edited by handed - good old fashioned HTML,CSS, and (maybe) JS. A site contained more
<marquee>s than pages, RIP marquee!, and the
querySelector wasn’t a thing.
Modern web development
Jumping ahead a few years (or 20) and now its not uncommon to start a project by deciding on the 5+ tools and platforms you will be bolting together. Do you want static site generation (SSG), server-side rendering (SSR), or client-side rendering(CSR)? Are you standing up and maintaining a backend server, or jumping on the serverless backend? Will plain CSS do the trick, or is SASS/SCSS/LESS your preferred approach? What about this CSS in JS and styled components madness?!?
Oh wait, you also need to host it somewhere. Does the project need continuous integration (CI) with automated testing, automated deployments, staging environments, etc? Better schedule another few days to decide on those tools, setup accounts, and bootstrap the basics together before you start coding!
Does it have to be so complicated?
No! Sure, all these tools and processes were created for good reason. CI can save a huge amount of time. Transpilers, build tools, and linters can help catch common mistakes and enforce team coding standards. Frontend frameworks can really be a lifesaver, especially if you need to build interfaces with complex interactivity and state management.
But all these advancements can turn into a real nightmare, too. Ever tried onboarding a new hire that is an experienced web developer but not familiar with the latest React trends like styled components or hooks? Is the time spent ramping up on these abstractions really worth the effort for a simple marketing site or statically hosted e-commerce store?
The tech stack you chose can be a much larger commitment than it first seems to be. I would be very surprised if react was no longer used a couple years down the road, but what about the 15 libraries you pull in to that react app?
If a project is built on an everything but the kitchen sink™ app platform like Nuxt.js, Next.js, or SvelteKit can really let you hit the ground running, but will they still be supported a few years down the road? Will developers still be excited to work with them, or will it be the butt of too many developers’ jokes like WordPress?
Keep it simple, stupid
Even better, these are all open standards that may evolve but will never go away.
What about this site though?
This very site is built with a shiny new SSG, Astro, isn’t that a bit hypocritical? I don’t think so, but hear me out!
Take a look at the sourcecode for this project and you’ll see that the real meat of the site is based entirely on the standards above. SCSS is used for styling, but honestly the only reason we even used that was because CSS nesting isn’t supported yet.
Most of the site’s pages are authored in markdown and various bits of data are stored in JSON.
Page templates and components are in
.css files or component-level
It would take a matter of a few hours to migrate the entire site to a different SSG, or even an entirely different platform like Next.js.
So yes, we’re technically using a few new build tools to wire templates together, but at the end of the day it’s easy to use Astro and forget that you aren’t using the basic, web-native HTML/CSS/JS stack.
Innovation is amazing, just don’t get stuck
It’s a very common mistake, especially for developers newer to web development, to get stuck on the hamster wheel chasing the latest toy. Don’t avoid innovation, just be strategic and selective in where you invest your time and efforts!
There’s always a new tool to try or pattern to learn, but at the end of the day it’s much more satisfying to ship a product rather than trying out a new tool with sample projects that never sees the light of day!
I feel like I bashed on react here - don’t get me wrong, react is an excellent and extremely powerful tool. React still has a huge lead in usage compared to the other frontend frameworks and, especially if you’re in the job market, it’s much easier to find job listing that require react experience than listings that don’t mention react at all. But if you find yourself running in circles, getting frustrated with a build pipeline that’s fighting you or magic hooks that you don’t understand, take a step back and learn the basic (boring) 20 year old tools. Ship fast, don’t break the build!